The Evolution of Scientific Evidence Theory in Criminal Law: A Transformative Insight
Downloads
Criminal law evolution accentuates the contrast between traditional eyewitness testimonies and precise modern forensics. While testimonies offer depth, scientific methodologies provide unparalleled accuracy in investigations. This study examines the challenges and merits of both in light of technological advancements. The objective is to understand the evolving paradigm of scientific evidence in criminal justice, emphasizing its integration and balance with traditional evidentiary methods for upholding judicial integrity and revealing material truth. The result of this study is historical evolution in the theory of scientific evidence which has transitioned from relying on testimonies to verifiable scientific data, including advancements in DNA and cyber technology. This scientific approach, characterized by its objectivity, replicability, and measurability, offers a robust foundation for discerning truth and justice, surpassing the limitations of mere factual accounts. Modern criminal law's integration of this evidence signifies a deep-rooted commitment to justice, ensuring verdicts are swift, fair, and grounded in undeniable truth.
Adam A, A History of Forensic Science: British Beginnings in the Twentieth Century (Routledge 2016).
Allen RJ and Smiciklas CK, ‘The Law's Aversion To Naked Statistics And Other Mistakes' (2022) 28 Legal Theory 179 <https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/S135232522200012X/type/journal_article>.
Alter Z, ‘Unpacking Frye-Mack: A Critical Analysis of Minnesota's Frye-Mack Standard for Admitting Scientific Evidence' (2017) 43 Mitchell Hamline Law Review <https://open.mitchellhamline.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1081&context=mhlr>.
Ansell C and Geyer R, ‘"Pragmatic Complexity” a New Foundation for Moving beyond "Evidence-Based Policy Making”?' [2016] Policy Studies 1 <https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01442872.2016.1219033>.
Arshad H, Jantan A Bin and Abiodun OI, ‘Digital Forensics: Review of Issues in Scientific Validation of Digital Evidence' (2018) 14 Journal of Information Processing Systems.
Bakardjiev DK, ‘Officer Body-Worn Cameras-Capturing Objective Evidence with Quality Technology and Focused Policies' (2015) 56 Jurimetrics.
Barrell H, Fatal Evidence: Professor Alfred Swaine Taylor & the Dawn of Forensic Science (Pen and Sword History 2017).
Behl A, Mishra A and Mishra IK, Tools and Techniques Used in Forensic DNA Typing (Springer 2021).
Bell S and others, ‘A Call for More Science in Forensic Science', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2018) <https://pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1712161115>.
Berry J and Stoney DA, ‘History and Development of Fingerprinting' in Henry C Lee and RE Gaensslen (eds), Advances in Fingerprint Technology (second edi, CRC Press 2001).
Biju A, Hambly K and Joshi A, ‘The Complexity of Forensic Science in Criminal Investigations: Is There a Gold Standard?' (2021) 1 Voices of Forensic Science.
Charman S, Bradfield A and Mook A, ‘Cognitive Bias in Legal Decision Making' [2019] Psychological science and the law.
CNN Editorial Research, ‘Casey Anthony Trial Fast Facts' (edition.cnn.com, 2022) <https://edition.cnn.com/2013/11/04/us/casey-anthony-trial-fast-facts/index.html>.
cnnindonesia, ‘Netizen Kembali Soroti Kasus Jessica Wongso Usai Lihat Ice Cold' (cnnindonesia.com, 2023) <https://www.cnnindonesia.com/hiburan/20231003141548-220-1006558/netizen-kembali-soroti-kasus-jessica-wongso-usai-lihat-ice-cold>.
de Waal Alberts A, ‘The Degree of the Lack of Regulation of Space Debris Within the Current Space Law Regime and Suggestions for a Prospective Legal Framework and Technological Interventions' in Annette Froehlich (ed), Space Security and Legal Aspects of Active Debris Removal (2019) <https://link.springer.com/10.1007/978-3-319-90338-5_6>.
Donoghue J, ‘The Rise of Digital Justice: Courtroom Technology, Public Participation and Access to Justice' (2017) 80 The Modern Law Review 995 <https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1468-2230.12300>.
Duster T, ‘A Post - genomic Surprise. The Molecular Reinscription of Race in Science, Law and Medicine' (2015) 66 The British Journal of Sociology 1 <https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1468-4446.12118>.
Easttom C, System Forensics, Investigation, and Response (Jones & Bartlett Learning 2017).
Edmond G and others, ‘Model Forensic Science' (2016) 48 Australian Journal of Forensic Sciences.
Edmond G and Martire KA, ‘Just Cognition: Scientific Research on Bias and Some Implications for Legal Procedure and Decision - Making' (2019) 82 The Modern Law Review 633 <https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1468-2230.12424>.
Engstrom EJ, Forensic Psychiatry: Human Science in the Borderlands Between Crime and Madness, In The Palgrave Handbook of the History of Human Sciences (Springer Singapore 2022).
Esposito C and others, ‘Esposito, C., Castiglione, A., Martini, B., & Choo, K. K. R. (2016). Cloud Manufacturing: Security, Privacy, and Forensic Concerns. IEEE Cloud Computing, 3(4)', (2016) 3 IEEE Cloud Computing.
Fabricant MC and Carrington WT, ‘The Shifted Paradigm: Forensic Sciences's Overdue Evolution from Magic to Law' (2016) 4 Virginia Journal of Criminal Law <http://www.ssrn.com/abstract=2572480>.
Fraser J, Forensic Science: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford University Press 2020).
Gabel Cino J, ‘Tackling Technical Debt: Managing Advances in DNA Technology That Outpace the Evolution of Law' (2016) 05 Journal of Civil & Legal Sciences <http://www.omicsgroup.org/journals/tackling-technical-debt-managing-advances-in-dna-technology-thatoutpace-the-evolution-of-law-2169-0170-1000183.php?aid=70590>.
Granot Y and others, ‘In the Eyes of the Law: Perception versus Reality in Appraisals of Video Evidence.' (2018) 24 Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 93 <https://doi.apa.org/doi/10.1037/law0000137>.
Gupta S and Jain IB, ‘Crime Scene Investigation And Forensic Evidence: Forensic Analysis And Tools' (2023) 14 Journal of Pharmaceutical Negative Results.
Harris HA and Lee HC, Introduction to Forensic Science and Criminalistics (CRC Press 2019) <https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781498757980>.
Head BW, ‘Toward More "Evidence - Informed” Policy Making?' (2016) 76 Public Administration Review 472 <https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/puar.12475>.
Heffer C, ‘Narrative in the Trial: Constructing Crime Stories in Court', The Routledge Handbook of Forensic Linguistics (2nd Editio, Routledge 2020).
Howes LM, ‘The Communication of Forensic Science in the Criminal Justice System: A Review of Theory and Proposed Directions for Research' (2015) 55 Science & Justice 145 <https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S1355030614001397>.
Illes M and Wilson P, The Scientific Method in Forensic Science: A Canadian Handbook (Canadian Scholars' Press 2020).
Isaac Abiodun O and others, ‘Data Provenance for Cloud Forensic Investigations, Security, Challenges, Solutions and Future Perspectives: A Survey' (2022) 34 Journal of King Saud University - Computer and Information Sciences 10217 <https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S131915782200369X>.
Kayser M, ‘Forensic Use of Y-Chromosome DNA: A General Overview' (2017) 136 Human Genetics 621 <http://link.springer.com/10.1007/s00439-017-1776-9>.
Klingele C, ‘Notre Dame Law Review The Promises and Perils of Evidence-Based Corrections Recommended Citation' (2016) 91 Notre Dame Law Review <http://www.bjs.gov/con->.
Koehler JA, ‘Making Crime a Science: The Rise of Evidence-Based Criminal Justice Policy' (University of California, Berkeley 2019).
Kraska P, Brent J and Neuman WL, Criminal Justice and Criminology Research Methods (Routledge 2020) <https://www.routledge.com/Criminal-Justice-and-Criminology-Research-Methods/Kraska-Brent-Neuman/p/book/9780367133948>.
Krishnan S and Shashidhar N, ‘Interplay of Digital Forensics in Ediscovery' (2021) 15 International Journal of Computer Science and Security (IJCSS) <https://www.cscjournals.org/manuscript/Journals/IJCSS/Volume15/Issue2/IJCSS-1602.pdf>.
Labuschagne G, The Profiler Diaries: From the Case Files of a Police Psychologist (Penguin Random House 2020).
Lechman E, The Diffusion of Information and Communication Technologies (Routledge 2017).
Leonetti C, ‘The History of Forensic-Science Evidence in Criminal Trials and the Role of Early "Success” in Establishing Its Putative Reliability' (2023) 54 St. Mary's Law Journal <https://commons.stmarytx.edu/thestmaryslawjournal/vol54/iss4/5/>.
Machado H and Granja R, Forensic Genetics in the Governance of Crime (Springer Nature 2020) <https://library.oapen.org/handle/20.500.12657/23264>.
Maclean C, Smith L and Dror I, ‘Experts on Trial: Unearthing Bias in Scientific Evidence' (2020) 53 University of British Columbia law review.
Marco B, ‘Human Rights Violations: Torture And Deprivation Of Liberty Examined' (2022) 7 Academic Journal of Legal Studies and Research.
McKinnon MC and others, ‘What Are the Effects of Nature Conservation on Human Well-Being? A Systematic Map of Empirical Evidence from Developing Countries' (2016) 5 Environmental Evidence 8 <https://environmentalevidencejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s13750-016-0058-7>.
Medwed DS, Wrongful Convictions and the DNA Revolution (Cambridge University Press 2017).
Memon A, Vrij A and Bull R, Psychology and Law: Truthfulness, Accuracy and Credibility (John Wiley & Sons 2003).
Milanovic M, ‘Establishing the Facts About Mass Atrocities: Accounting for the Failure of the ICTY to Persuade Target Audiences' [2016] Georgetown Journal of International Law, Forthcoming <https://ssrn.com/abstract=2757151>.
Narem UA, ‘DNA Profiling & Forensic Science: From Tracing Evolutionary Discoveries to the DNA Technology (Use & Application) Regulation Bill, 2018' (2019) 9 Supremo Amicus <https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3986257>.
Nesson C, ‘The Evidence or the Event? On Judicial Proof and the Acceptability of Verdicts' in Scott Brewer (ed), Logic, Probability, and Presumptions in Legal Reasoning (Routledge 2013).
Paterline DBA, ‘Forensic Hypnosis and the Courts' (2016) 4 Journal of Law and Criminal Justice <http://jlcjnet.com/vol-4-no-2-december-2016-abstract-1-jlcj>.
Pathak SK, ‘Forensic Science's Impact: DNA Tests and Narco-Analysis Evidentiary Relevance' (2022) 2 Jus Corpus Law Journal.
Pinelopi A, ‘Computer and Network Forensics: Investigating Network Traffic' (International Hellenic University 2017) <https://repository.ihu.edu.gr/xmlui/handle/11544/29161?show=full>.
Prakken H and Kaptein H, Legal Evidence and Proof: Statistics, Stories, Logic (Routledge 2016).
Primorac D and Schanfield M, Forensic DNA Applications (CRC Press 2023) <https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9780429019944>.
Pyrek KM, Pioneers in Forensic Science: Innovations and Issues in Practice (CRC Press 2017).
Robertson B, Vignaux GA and Berger CEH, Interpreting Evidence: Evaluating Forensic Science In The Courtroom (John Wiley & Sons 2016) <https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/book/10.1002/9781118492475>.
Rossmo DK, ‘Case Rethinking: A Protocol for Reviewing Criminal Investigations' (2016) 17 Police Practice and Research 212 <https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15614263.2014.978320>.
Safia R, Rahmi EM and Nurhayati S, ‘Bentuk Perlidungan Hukum Dari Lembaga Perlindungan Saksi/Korban Di Indonesia Dan Inggris' (2022) 1 Jurnal Ekonomi, Bisnis dan Humaniora <https://eksishum.untara.ac.id/index.php/eksishum/article/view/12>.
Sellers BG and Arrigo BA, ‘The Narrative Framework of Psychological Jurisprudence: Virtue Ethics as Criminal Justice Practice' (2022) 63 Aggression and Violent Behavior 101671 <https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S1359178921001257>.
Sitompul J, ‘Improving the Role of Experts under Indonesian Criminal Procedure Law: Lessons Learned From the Dutch Legal System' (2018) 8 Indonesia Law Review <https://scholarhub.ui.ac.id/ilrev/vol8/iss1/5>.
Subhandi Bakhtiar H, ‘Pentingnya Bukti Forensik Pada Pembuktian Tindak Pidana' (2022) 3 Jurnal Hukum Pidana dan Kriminologi 36 <http://jurnalmahupiki.org/ojs/index.php/jhpk/article/view/82>.
Syukriani YF, Novita N and Sunjaya DK, ‘Development of Forensic Medicine in Post Reform Indonesia' (2018) 58 Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 56 <https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S1752928X1830252X>.
Tim Ott, ‘Amanda Knox: A Complete Timeline of Her Italian Murder Case and Trial' (biography.com, 2007) <https://www.biography.com/crime/amanda-knox-murder-trial-timeline-facts>.
Waluyo B, Penegakan Hukum Di Indonesia (Sinar Grafika 2022).
Zaidan MA, Menuju Pembaruan Hukum Pidana (Sinar Grafika 2022).
Copyright (c) 2024 Handar Subhandi Bakhtiar
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
